Just ask Howard T. Owens, executive producer of Nashville Star, a long-running reality competition to find Americas next country singing superstar.
Unlike Idol, Owens says his show always has and always will feature a live band playing along with contestants, as well as contestants who play instruments and write their own songs.
He believes Idol has mimicked the authenticity of Nashville Star over the last few seasons by adding a live band instead of pre-recorded tracks during singers performances and more recently, allowing the singers to play instruments on stage.
Still, in Owens eyes, Idol has fallen short.
He doesnt buy the attempts at showing musicians like ousted dreadlocked singer Jason Castro playing guitar on stage.
Owens says, When Jason Castro played guitar, you never saw a shot of his fingers! It was ridiculous. At Nashville Star we dont try to use a guitar as a fake prop. We want to explore our contestants real musical abilities.
The sixth season of Nashville Star premieres June 9 on NBC.
(Contact numbers available only to subscribing media or trial media users. You can request samples at the Wireless Flash web site.)
Copyright © 2008 Wireless Flash News Inc. All rights reserved. Wireless Flash® and FlashNews® are registered trademarks of Wireless Flash News Inc.